GST Decoded: Is Your Business Missing Out on the Magic of Input Tax Credit (ITC)? The Mechanics of Supply and the Efficiency of Input Tax Credit (ITC)

Written by: SALLY NCUBE, B.A.LL.B, LOVELY PROFESSIONAL UNIVERSITY

1. Introduction: The Death of "Tax on Tax" 

Imagine buying a simple birthday cake. Under the old indirect tax regime in  India, the process was a labyrinth of hidden costs. You were taxed for the flour  (Excise Duty), then taxed again for the sugar (VAT), and then taxed on the entire cake—effectively paying a tax on the taxes already paid for the ingredients. This phenomenon, known as the "cascading effect," resulted in high prices for consumers and massive inefficiencies for businesses.  

The Goods and Services Tax (GST), which went into effect on July 1, 2017,  was a fundamental reform of the Indian economy rather than merely a change in legislation. GST sought to make India a "One Nation, One Tax, One Market"  reality by consolidating a dozen central and state taxes into a single taxable event—Supply—and bolstering it with the ground-breaking Input Tax Credit  (ITC) mechanism. 

This blog examines the two foundations of GST: the ITC structure, which acts as the "magic coupon" for corporate expansion, and the broad definition of supply, which establishes tax responsibility. Knowing these mechanics can make the difference between a successful bottom line and a compliance nightmare, regardless of your size, whether you are a little retailer or a major manufacturer. 

2.The Business Engine: Understanding "Supply" 

In the pre-GST era, tax triggers varied: Excise was triggered by "manufacture,"  VAT by "sale," and Service Tax by the "provision of service." GST simplified  this by creating a single taxable event: Supply – 

Scope of Supply (Section 7) 

Under Section 7 of the CGST Act, the term "Supply" is defined expansively. It  includes all forms of supply of goods or services, such as:  

Sale and Transfer: The standard exchange of goods for money. Barter and Exchange: Trading goods for other goods (both are taxable). 

License, Lease, Rental: Providing use of an asset without transferring ownership. 

Disposal: Scrapping or giving away business assets. 

For a transaction to qualify as a supply, it generally requires two elements: it must be made for a consideration (payment) and in the course or furtherance of business. However, there are exceptions (Schedule I) where supplies without consideration between related persons are still taxable to ensure the credit chain remains unbroken.  

Understanding the "Place of Supply" and "Time of Supply" further determines which state gets the tax and exactly when the liability arises, preventing arbitrary tax demands and providing certainty to the taxpayer. 

3. The Bundle Dilemma: Composite vs Mixed Supply 

In modern commerce, goods and services are rarely sold in isolation.  Businesses frequently "bundle" offerings to enhance value. GST categorises these into two distinct buckets under Section 2(30) and 2(74).  

A. Composite Supply [Section 2(30)] 

A composite supply consists of two or more taxable supplies of goods or services which are naturally bundled and supplied in conjunction with each other in the ordinary course of business.  

The Rule: One item is the "Principal Supply." The tax rate of the principal supply applies to the entire bundle. 

The Classic Example: A flight ticket includes an in-flight meal and insurance.  The passenger's primary intent is travel (Principal Supply). Therefore, the entire ticket cost is taxed at the rate applicable to air transport, even if the meal separately would have a higher or lower rate. 

B. Mixed Supply [Section 2(74)] 

A mixed supply comprises two or more individual supplies made together for a single price, but they are not naturally bundled.  

The Rule: The entire bundle is taxed at the highest rate applicable to any item inside the package. 

The Classic Example: A Diwali gift hamper containing chocolates (18%),  canned juice (12%), and dry fruits (5%) sold for a single price. Since these can be sold separately, it is a mixed supply. The entire hamper will be taxed at 18%.

The visual representation above highlights that while GST is a  "destination-based consumption tax," it is collected at every point in the supply chain. The middle players (manufacturers and traders) act as collection agents for the government, only paying the tax on the value they themselves have added to the product.  

5. The Powerhouse: How ITC Works 

The foundation of GST is the Input Tax Credit (ITC). This system enables a taxpayer to deduct the tax they owe on their output from the tax they have already paid on their inputs.  

Output tax on sales less input tax on purchases equals net tax payable.  GST would merely be an additional layer of the outdated, dysfunctional system in the absence of ITC. ITC makes sure that the tax solely affects the ultimate customer and has no effect on the company. To "claim the magic," a  company needs to fulfil a few non-negotiable requirements outlined in Section  16: 

Possession of Invoice: A current tax invoice or debit note is required for the buyer.  

Receipt of Goods/Services: The products must have been delivered to the buyer. 

Tax Paid to Government: The supplier must have actually paid the tax collected from the buyer to the government. 

Filing of Returns: The buyer must have filed their monthly GST returns (GSTR 3B). 

This creates a self-policing loop. If your supplier doesn't pay the tax or file their return, you lose your credit. This encourages businesses to deal only with compliant, law-abiding partners. 

Page 5 

6. Case Study: The Journey of a 

Leather Jacket 

Let's track the tax journey of a premium leather jacket to see how ITC  eliminates the "Tax on Tax" nightmare.  

The Tanner (Raw Material): Sells leather to the manufacturer for  ₹1,000 + 12% GST (₹120).  

Government receives: ₹120. 

The Manufacturer: Adds value by sewing and designing. Sells to the  Wholesaler for ₹2,000 + 12% GST (₹240).  

Instead of paying ₹240, the manufacturer uses the ₹120 credit from the leather.  

Manufacturer Pays: ₹240 - ₹120 = ₹120.  

The Wholesaler: Sells to a Retailer for ₹2,500 + 12% GST (₹300).  The Wholesaler has a ₹240 credit.  

Wholesaler Pays: ₹300 - ₹240 = ₹60.  

Total Tax Collected: ₹120 (Tanner) + ₹120 (Manufacturer) + ₹60  (Wholesaler) = ₹300.  

Observation: The final tax (₹300) is exactly 12% of the final sale price  (₹2,500). No tax was charged on the previous taxes. The system remained perfectly linear and fair. 

7. Compliance: The Modern 

Business Challenge 

While the "magic" of ITC is powerful, it is not automatic. Modern businesses face significant compliance hurdles that require sophisticated accounting and digital integration.  

The Matching Principle 

Government restrictions on ITC have been increased with the advent of GSTR 2B, an automatically generated read-only statement. Only credit that appears on a company's GSTR-2B, which is produced using the sales information that suppliers have provided, may be claimed. The most important monthly activity for any GST-registered firm is this "reconciliation" procedure.  

Credits Blocked (Section 17(5)) 

Not all business purchases are eligible for the ITC. Even when used for business  purposes, the law "blocks" credit for several items:  

Motor vehicles are typically prohibited unless they are utilised for certain reasons, such as driving schools, or for the movement of commodities.  

Food and Drinks: Unless required by law, credit for worker meals or outdoor catering is typically prohibited. 

Personal Consumption: Any goods used for personal use cannot have their tax offset. 

Lost or Stolen Goods: If goods are destroyed or written off, the corresponding  ITC must be reversed.

Misclaiming blocked credit can lead to heavy penalties and interest (currently  18% per annum), making it essential for businesses to have robust tax filtration systems.  

8. Why This Matters for Economic Growth 

The mechanics of Supply and ITC do more than just simplify bookkeeping;  they are strategic levers for the Indian economy.  

Developing a National Market  

Before the introduction of the GST, crossing state lines required paying "Entry  Tax" or "Octroi." Even when items go from Mumbai to Delhi, the credit chain is kept intact according to the Integrated GST (IGST) mechanism. This lowers the time and cost of logistics, increasing the competitiveness of Indian goods worldwide.  

Lower Prices for Customers 

The effective tax rate on the majority of essential items has actually dropped since the GST was implemented due to the removal of the tax-on-tax. The effectiveness of the ITC chain has reduced the overall "cost of living" impact,  even while some services have increased in price. 

Encouraging Formalization 

Because businesses want to claim ITC, they prefer buying from registered GST  taxpayers. This "peer-pressure" has forced thousands of informal businesses to register for GST, expanding the national tax base and creating a more transparent financial ecosystem. 

Page 8 

Conclusion 

GST is a strategic framework for economic efficiency and much more than a treasury instrument. Businesses can achieve financial optimisation by understanding the intricacies of the "Supply" and "ITC" systems, going beyond simple compliance. The "Magic of ITC" in the present day is about creating a transparent, competitive, and resilient business in a rapidly changing global market, not just about saving money. 

9. Appendix: Statutory Definitions & References

Supply	Section 7,  CGST Act	The core taxable event involving  transfer, barter, or lease of goods/  services.
Composite  Supply	Section 2(30),  CGST Act	Naturally bundled supplies; taxed at  the rate of the principal supply.
Mixed Supply	Section 2(74),  CGST Act	Independent items sold for one price;  taxed at the highest item's rate.
Input Tax  Credit	Section 16,  CGST Act	The right to offset tax paid on inputs  against output liability.
Ineligible ITC	Section 17(5),  CGST Act	List of goods/services where credit is  blocked (e.g., motor vehicles).

References  

• The Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Act, 2017: The foundational  legislation for GST in India. 

• GST Council Secretariat: Concept notes on "Seamless Flow of Credit" and "E Invoicing Ecosystem." 

• ICAI (The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India): Technical Guide on  GST Input Tax Credit (Latest Edition). 

• CBIC (Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs): Official GST Flyers and  FAQ database.

Volume 2 | Issue 1