Custodial Torture And Rights Of Prisoners In India: A Critical Analysis Of Legal Framework, Implementation Gaps, And Pathways For Reform

Written by:  Vasant Subhash Sonawane, LL.M, Modern Law College, Pune

Published on: 13^th March 2026

Abstract

Custodial torture remains a pervasive human rights crisis in India, undermining the constitutional guarantee of dignity under Article 21 and eroding public trust in the criminal justice system. Despite landmark judicial interventions like D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal (1997) and guidelines from the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC), statistics reveal alarming persistence: the NHRC reported approximately 2,739 custodial deaths in 2024 (up from ~2,400 in 2023), with thousands more in judicial custody annually. Overcrowding (national prison occupancy at 131.4%), impunity (zero convictions for 1,107 police custodial deaths between 2011-2022 per NCRB-linked data), and the absence of a specific anti-torture law exacerbate the issue.

This paper examines the historical roots, constitutional and statutory framework, international obligations, forms of abuse, prisoners' rights, judicial safeguards, institutional challenges, and reform recommendations. Drawing on NHRC reports, NCRB Prison Statistics India 2023, Supreme Court jurisprudence, and the Global Torture Index 2025 (classifying India as "high risk"), it argues that systemic impunity stems from colonial-era laws and weak accountability. Urgent ratification of the UN Convention Against Torture (UNCAT), legislative reforms, and prison modernization are essential to uphold prisoners' rights.

Keywords: Custodial torture, prisoners’ rights, Article 21, human dignity, police brutality, custodial deaths, prison reforms, criminal justice system, human rights law, constitutional protections

article 7.pdf

Download PDF • 255KB

Volume 2 | Issue 3